江西财经大学学报 ›› 2022, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (4): 123-135.

• 法与经济 • 上一篇    下一篇

增值税抵扣权之证成:一场内部与外部证成理论的辩论

褚睿刚   

  1. 首都经济贸易大学 法学院,北京 100070
  • 收稿日期:2021-09-18 出版日期:2022-07-25 发布日期:2022-08-10
  • 作者简介:褚睿刚,首都经济贸易大学讲师,法学博士,主要从事经济法与财税法研究,联系方式churuigang@163.com。
  • 基金资助:
    法治建设与法学理论研究部级科研项目青年课题“数字经济增值税立法问题研究”(21SFB3022); 江西省高校人文社会科学研究青年项目“数字经济增值税规则研究”(FX20205)

The Justification of the VAT Deduction Right: A Debate between Internal and External Justification Theories

CHU Rui-gang   

  1. Capital University of Economics and Business, Beijing 100070, China
  • Received:2021-09-18 Online:2022-07-25 Published:2022-08-10

摘要: 作为增值税纳税人核心权利的抵扣权,只有摆脱道德层面虚实难定的“权利”声称,被确证为真正存在的实在法权利,才能更好地发挥国家课税权制约和纳税人权益保护的双重功效,引导增值税制优化,撬动增值税法实践困局。通过权利内部证成即可完成此种身份转换。抵扣权内部证成虽以权利的内在理由为论据,但该过程意在描述权利如何从其所处的环境中获取这种资格的动态过程,须借助评价性搭建权利与外在环境之间的连接桥梁。因此,论证过程包括本体和涉他两大核心构造,一方面评价权利本身,描绘权利自身的正当性和重要性;另一方面评价内外互动,展现抵扣权之于外在环境的正当性和重要性。具言之,一方面从权利基础法理切入,论证抵扣权契合权利的内置机理;另一方面要进行规范考察,证成抵扣权恪守增值税法的法律品格。

关键词: 抵扣权, 增值税, 内部证成, 新兴权利

Abstract: The deduction right, as the core right of a taxpayerof value-added tax, can play a better role in the double function of the restriction of the state's taxing power and the protection of the rights and interests of taxpayers only if it gets rid of the“right”claim that is difficult to determine from the moral level and is confirmed as a real positive law right. Then it can guide the optimization of the value-added tax system and leverage the practical difficulties of the value-added tax law. This identity conversion can be accomplished through the internal justification of the rights. Although the internal justification of the right of deduction is based on the inherent reasons of the right, the process is intended to describe the dynamic process of how the right obtains this qualification from the environment in which it is located. The connecting bridge between the rights and the external environment should be built with the help of the evaluation. Therefore, the argumentation process consists of two core structures: the ontology and the reference. On the one hand, it evaluates the right itself, describing its legitimacy and importance; on the other hand, it evaluates the internal-external interaction, showing the legitimacy and importance of deduction right to the external environment. In a word, on the one hand, we should start from the basic legal theory of rights to demonstrate the built-in mechanism of the deduction right conforming to the right; on the other hand, we should conduct standardized investigation to justify the legal character of the deduction right being abided by the law of VAT.

Key words: deduction right, value-added tax, internal justification, emerging rights

中图分类号: