江西财经大学学报 ›› 2020, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (2): 115-127.

• 法与经济 • 上一篇    下一篇

个人信息保护中知情同意规则的坚守与修正

宁园   

  1. 武汉大学 法学院,湖北 武汉 430072
  • 收稿日期:2019-11-08 出版日期:2020-03-25 发布日期:2020-12-14
  • 作者简介:宁 园,武汉大学博士研究生,主要从事民法研究,联系方式ny4959456@163.com。
  • 基金资助:
    国家法治与法学理论研究项目“数据确权与交易法律问题”(18SFB2031)

Insisting on and Revision of the Informed Consent Rule in Personal Information Protection

NING Yuan   

  1. Wuhan University, Wuhan 430072, China
  • Received:2019-11-08 Online:2020-03-25 Published:2020-12-14

摘要: 形式大于实质、负外部性明显、背离个人信息社会属性的缺陷等驱使否定论者试图弱化甚至摒弃知情同意规则,因此有必要打破上述质疑,重塑知情同意规则的正当性。知情同意规则是实现个人信息保护的风险防范实质的必要途径,寄希望于风险防范功能孱弱的事后责任规则并不可取。知情同意规则的经济负外部性被夸大,其与数据经济发展和创新的内在一致性应被充分认识。坚守和完善知情同意规则才是长远之计。一方面,知情同意规则应与个人信息自决权解绑,其既不派生绝对权,也未背离个人信息的社会属性;另一方面,知情同意规则是个人信息保护的一般规则,应细化告知义务以保证同意满足实质要素和形式要素。

关键词: 个人信息保护, 知情同意规则, 风险防范, 同意要素, 告知义务

Abstract: Such imperfections as a form being bigger than its essence, obvious negative externality, inconsistence with the social attributes of personal information and so on will drive the negativists to try to weaken or even abandon the informed consent rule, thus it is necessary to remove the above-mentioned doubts and reshape the legitimacy of the informed-consent rule. The informed consent rule is a necessary path to realize the risk prevention essence of personal information protection. It is not desirable to pin one's hope on the afterwards responsibility rule that has weaker risk prevention function. The economic negative externality of the informed consent rule is exaggerated; its inherent consistency with data economic development and innovation should be fully recognized. To insisting on and to improve the informed-consent rule is the long-term solution. On the one hand, the informed consent rule should be untied from the right of self-determination on personal information, not deriving absolute right, nor deviating from the social attribute of personal information. On the other hand, since the informed consent rule is a general rule to protect personal information, the obligation to disclose should be detailed, so as to ensure that the individual's consent meets the corresponding substantive and formal elements.

Key words: protection of personal data, informed consent rule, risk prevention, elements of consent, obligation to disclose

中图分类号: