江西财经大学学报 ›› 2015, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (02): 471-.

• •    

美国侵权法中连带责任制度的改革方案及其启示

关长宇1,尚希文2   

  1. (1. 中共中央组织部 老干部处,北京 100815;2. 贵州省法庄律师事务所,贵州 贵阳 558000)
  • 发布日期:2021-01-21
  • 作者简介:关长宇,中共中央组织部研究人员,管理学硕士,主要从事民商法研究,联系方式guannk@163.com;尚希文,贵州省法庄律师事务所律师,主要从事民商法研究。

The Reform on the Joint and Several Liability in American Tort Law and Its Enlightenment

GUAN Chang-yu, SHANG Xi-wen   

  1. (The Organizing Department of the Central Committee of CPC, Beijing 100815; Fazhuang Law Firm, Guiyang 558000, China)
  • Published:2021-01-21

摘要: 在美国,连带责任制度一度成为法官用作判案依据的宠儿,但其大行其道的同时也暴露出了诸多问题。随着美国侵权法改革拉开帷幕,连带责任制度也受到了巨大冲击。经过数十年的激烈辩论后,侵权法改革最终呈现出一种以连带责任适用受到限制的状态。在中国,也存在连带责任滥用和混用现象,因此,结合美国连带责任制度的发展变迁,中国连带责任制度应引入“事后二次分担”理论来加以完善,使相关权利人的利益得到更好的保护。

关键词: 美国侵权法,连带责任,分摊请求权,二次分担规则,“深口袋”现象

Abstract: In the United States, the joint and several liability was once the favorite of the judges in their judgments. However, lots of issues have been revealed when it was prevailing in the courts. Along with the beginning of the reform of American Tort Law, the joint and several liability has been suffering a great impact. After years of intense debate, the reform of the tort law finally led to the result of restricted application of the joint and several liability. In China, there also exist abuses of the joint and several liability. Therefore, by referring to the development and changes of American joint and several liability, China’s joint and several liability system should be improved by introducing the theory of post redistribution, so that the interests of the related obligees can be better protected.

Key words: American tort law; joint and several liability; the right of contribution; redistribution rule; deep pocket phenomenon