当代财经 ›› 2019, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (08): 1868-.

• • 上一篇    

合约成本、激励效应与政府间税收划分逻辑

石子印   

  1. (聊城大学 商学院,山东 聊城 252059)
  • 收稿日期:2018-12-17 发布日期:2021-01-21
  • 作者简介:石子印,聊城大学教授,中国社会科学院博士后,博士,主要从事中央和地方财政关系研究,作者联系方式zyshi01@126.com。

Contract Cost, Incentive Effect and Logic of Inter-Governmental Tax Division

SHI Zi-yin   

  1. (Liaocheng University, Liaocheng 252059, China)
  • Received:2018-12-17 Published:2021-01-21

摘要: 合约理论表明,如果地区间资源禀赋和经济发展存在较大差异,那么各地区应该有不同的税收留成率,这种设置才是有效率的。有多种合约能够实现这种差异留成率,但需要在权衡合约成本与激励效应基础上按照净收益最大化进行选择。在实践中,我国有通过设定不同税收分享比例而直接实现地方税收留成率差异的合约,也有通过不同转移支付规模而间接实现留成率差异的合约。相比而言,税收分成制能够平衡税收划分的合约成本与激励效应,是实现地方税收差异留成率的恰当形式。目前我国的分成制合约存在缺陷,需要从两个方面来实现政府间税收划分合约的净收益最大化目标:一是降低地方支出责任比重,以降低转移支付规模;二是增加地方政府固定税种,以降低增值税分享比例。

关键词: 政府间税收划分,税收分成制,合约成本,激励效应

Abstract: The contract theory shows that if there are large differences in regional resource endowment and economic development, these regions should have different tax retention rates, and this kind of setting will be efficient. Many kinds of contracts can achieve this differential retention rate, but we need to choose the appropriate contract base on weighing the contract cost and incentive effect according to net revenue maximization. In practice, China has two kinds of contracts, one is directly realizing local tax retention rate differential by setting different tax sharing ratios, the other is indirectly realizing local tax retention rate differential by different scale of transfer payment. In comparison, the tax sharing system is an appropriate form which can balance the cost and incentive effect of tax division so as to realize differential local tax retention rates. But there are some shortcomings in the current share system contract, it is necessary to realize the goal of net revenue maximization of inter-governmental tax division contracts in two ways: one is to reduce the proportion of local expenditure responsibility in order to reduce the scale of transfer payments, the other is to increase the fixed tax items of local governments in order to reduce the proportion of value-added tax sharing.

Key words: inter-governmental tax division; tax sharing system; contract costs; incentive effect