江西财经大学学报 ›› 2026, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (1): 127-136.

• 法与经济 • 上一篇    

禁止权利滥用原则构成国际法一般法律原则的分析

王丽华   

  1. 上海政法学院 国际法学院,上海 201701
  • 收稿日期:2025-06-08 修回日期:2025-11-23 出版日期:2026-01-25 发布日期:2026-02-09
  • 作者简介:王丽华,上海政法学院教授,博士生导师,主要从事国际法、国际税法研究,联系方式 pollywlh@126.com。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金一般项目“上合组织数据安全法律治理机制研究”(22BFX160)

An Analysis of the Principle of Prohibition of Abuse of Rights as a General Principle of International Law

Wang Li-hua   

  1. Shanghai University of Political Science and Law, Shanghai 201701, China
  • Received:2025-06-08 Revised:2025-11-23 Online:2026-01-25 Published:2026-02-09

摘要: 禁止权利滥用原则作为各国国内法的基本原则,其核心在于防止形式上合法的权利以实质不当的方式被行使。该原则能否因“被各国承认”而上升为国际法的一般法律原则,长期存在争议。联合国大会《一般法律原则第二次报告》提出了识别国内法原则能否转化为国际法一般法律原则的“两步法”。依此方法检视可知,禁止权利滥用原则已在世界主要法律体系中普遍存在,并具备在国际法框架下适用的可行性与必要性,因而足以确立为国际法的一般法律原则。国际司法实践普遍承认该原则在国际法中的地位,但在具体适用上仍存在争议,包括国家是否具有损害他国利益的意图、权利行使目的是否正当、行使权利的方式是否合理以及滥用权利的证明标准等问题。鉴于该原则在国际争端解决中的独特功能,有必要从理论构建、制度完善与司法适用三个层面协同推进,以摆脱其在实践中面临的困境。

关键词: 禁止权利滥用原则, 一般法律原则, 司法适用

Abstract: The principle of prohibiting the abuse of rights, as a fundamental principle of domestic law in various countries, aims to prevent formally legitimate rights from being exercised in a substantially inappropriate manner. There has long been controversy over whether this principle can be elevated to a general legal principle of international law due to its recognition by various countries. The Second Report of the United Nations General Assembly on General Principles of Law proposes a two-step approach to identifying whether domestic legal principles can be transformed into general legal principles of international law. According to this method of examination, it can be concluded that the principle of prohibiting the abuse of rights has been widely present in major legal systems around the world and has the feasibility and necessity to be applied within the framework of international law. Therefore, it is sufficient to establish it as a general legal principle of international law. The international judicial practice generally recognizes the status of this principle in international law, but there are still controversies in its specific application, including whether the state has the intention to harm the interests of other countries, whether the purpose of exercising the rights is legitimate, whether the way of exercising the rights is reasonable, and the standards for proving the abuse of rights. Given the unique function of this principle in international dispute resolution, it is necessary to promote it in a coordinated manner from three levels: theoretical construction, institutional improvement, and judicial application, so as to overcome the difficulties it faces in practice.

Key words: principle of prohibition of abuse of rights, general principles of law, judicial application

中图分类号: